I Want to Validate Summer Reed Diffuser Longevity Claims — How Do I Measure Both Liquid Remaining and Actual Fragrance Performance?
शेयर करना
I Want to Validate Summer Reed Diffuser Longevity Claims — How Do I Measure Both Liquid Remaining and Actual Fragrance Performance?
Half full and odourless is a failure, not a passWeight remaining is not fragrance remainingStocked in India · ships nationwide
CSI diffuser guides · two instruments, one date
A longevity claim has two halves and most validation only checks one. The scale tells you how much liquid is left. A blind panel tells you whether the bottle still smells of anything. A bottle that is half full and odourless has failed, and it will pass any check that only weighs. Validation therefore means two readings at the same date, and the claim survives only if both of them do.
★★★★★
"Good product👍"
Sooraj RVerified buyer · Jul 2026
Reed & Car Diffuser Base
★★★★★
"Nice product"
snehal ChaudharyVerified buyer · May 2026
Gold Reed Diffuser Bottle
★★★★★
"I am really happy with this fragrance.Its absolutely overwhelming fragrance. I used it in champagne candle and received a very positive review from my customer."
Ranjita RAOVerified buyer · Feb 2026
Orchard Pear Fragrance Oil
★★★★★
"Fragrance is awesome. Hot throw is also very good after burn candle."
AkanshaVerified buyer · Dec 2025
Lavender Fragrance Oil
★★★★★
"Quality is good with good fragrance"
Avanthi CheeliVerified buyer · Nov 2025
Citrus Lemon Fragrance Oil
★★★★★
"Really nice fragrance, we continue our shopping going forward."
Uchu OmoideVerified buyer · Sep 2025
Fresh Strawberries Fragrance Oil
★★★★★
"Frangance is sooo good"
Sneha TamangVerified buyer · May 2025
Cinnamon Vanilla Fragrance Oil
★★★★★
"Good"
R.G.Jun 2024
Roasted Coffee Fragrance Oil
★★★★★
"Fragrance oil is sooo good smell so good we love it a lot"
Arshad ShaikhVerified buyer · Mar 2026
British Rose Fragrance Oil
★★★★★
"One of the best fragrance oils"
AnonymousVerified buyer · Jul 2025
Dark Vanilla Fragrance Oil
Reviews collected and published through Judge.me on candlemakingsuppliesindia.store, unedited. Every one of them is a single early reading on one instrument — a nose, once, with nothing beside it. None has a weight, a date, a reference bottle or a second unit, so none of them validates anything about longevity; most are candle observations rather than diffuser ones.
✓ No shelf life or longevity figure is published for anything✓ No oil is described as holding up in heat✓ Bulk pricing & GST invoicing on WhatsApp
CSI Diffuser Guides · Two-Instrument Validation
I Want to Validate Summer Reed Diffuser Longevity Claims — How Do I Measure Both Liquid Remaining and Actual Fragrance Performance?
The question has the right shape, because a longevity claim is two claims wearing one number. "Lasts 45 days" asserts both that there is still liquid in the bottle on day 45 and that the room still smells of something on day 45, and those are measured by two completely different instruments. A ₹354 scale answers the first. A blind panel against a sealed twin from the same batch answers the second. There is no instrument that answers both, and weight remaining does not tell you how much fragrance remains — so a bottle that is half full and odourless passes every check that only weighs, which is exactly how the failure mode nobody catches gets onto a label.
2 of 2
A longevity claim is validated only when both instruments pass on the claim date. Either one failing fails the claim — and the pair has to be read on the same day, on more than one unit, in the condition most of your customers are actually in
Quick answers — read this first
What are the two instruments? A weighing scale for liquid remaining and a blind panel against a sealed 12 ml twin for whether it still smells. Two tracks, two columns, same date.
Why not just weigh? Because weight remaining is not fragrance remaining. The base and the oil need not leave in the same proportion, and no data on that is published for anything — so a half-full bottle may contain almost no fragrance.
Name the failure mode.Liquid present, odour gone. On the reader's own figures a bottle can be 51.3% full at day 45 and judged near-silent — which looks like a pass on the shelf and is a return in the post.
How many readings?Eight reading pairs in a two-unit, four-date validation: each pair is one weight plus one coded verdict against a twin opened once.
What does it cost?₹3,491 cash out, ₹1,275.08 consumed — so ₹436.38 cash and ₹159.39 consumed per reading pair.
Will a slower base help? It may make the silent failure more likely. A slower base can buy days and spend throw, so judge it on both readings, never on days alone.
The short answer
Read both instruments on the same date: weigh the bottle cap off and reeds in, then run a coded same-or-different judgement against a sealed twin from the same batch. Two entries, one line, one date. A claim passes only 2 of 2.
Name the quadrant you landed in: liquid and odour both present is a pass; liquid present and odour gone is the silent failure; empty but fragrant to the end means the claim date is the empty date; empty and silent is an ordinary end of life.
Never infer odour from grams: no density, no evaporation rate and no differential-loss data is published for any base or oil, so the fraction of your remaining liquid that is fragrance is not a number anybody can give you.
The two instruments produce two independent answers, and crossing them gives four outcomes rather than a single verdict. Only the top-left box is a validated claim date. The heavy box is the one that matters commercially: a bottle still half full, smelling of nothing, which looks healthy on a shelf and reads as a pass to anyone who only weighs. The bottom-left box is a different problem with a different fix — the product was still working when the liquid ran out, which points at reed count and fill rather than at the oil.
How do I validate a reed diffuser longevity claim using both liquid remaining and actual fragrance performance?
Treat the claim as two assertions and test each with its own instrument on the same date. Instrument one is a ₹354 weighing scale. Record each bottle's empty weight before filling and its net fill at day 0 after the published 1–2 hour reed absorption; from then on every weighing is taken cap off, reeds in, at the same hour, and liquid remaining is a percentage of that recorded net fill. Instrument two is a blind panel against a sealed twin. Fill a 12 ml attar bottle at ₹36 from the same mix at bottling time for every reading date you intend to have, keep them capped and cool, and open each exactly once: at a reading date you present the running bottle and the twin coded and in random order and ask only same or different, with a sentence if different. Now the rule that makes it validation rather than a diary: a claim passes a date only if both instruments pass it. Liquid remaining with the panel saying "same" is a pass. Liquid remaining with the panel saying "different, almost nothing" is a failure — and it is the failure that gets shipped, because the bottle looks fine. On the reader's own figures a 120 g net fill losing 1.3 g a day is still 51.3% full at day 45; weigh it and you would call that a comfortable pass. The one inference you must never make is from the scale to the nose. Weight remaining is not fragrance remaining: the base and the oil do not have to leave the bottle in the same proportion, and no density, evaporation rate or differential-loss data is published for any base or any oil — so there is no arithmetic, anywhere, that turns grams left into fragrance left. Two further limits. A published figure needs more than one unit run to full life, stated as a conservative value or a reproducible range with its assumptions attached, and validated per fragrance rather than once across a collection. And a warm or hot bench run screens for change, never for life: there is no acceleration factor for this product, published or derivable, so no cupboard brings a day-45 reading forward.
One line: weigh it, smell it blind against a twin, write both on one line with the date — and if either reading fails, the claim fails, however healthy the bottle looks.
The two-unit, four-date validation: one 120 ML Pack of 10 at ₹1,062 (two used, eight spare), 16 reeds from one ₹236 Pack of 25, one ₹1,099 base pack (180 ml used), one ₹380 Orchard Pear 100 gm pack and eight sealed 12 ml twins from a ₹360 pack of ten.
One of them is a measurement. The other is a judgement. Neither can stand in for the other.
It helps to be precise about what each instrument is good for, because the temptation is always to let the easier one answer both questions. The scale is a measurement. It produces a number, in grams, that another person with another scale would reproduce. It is cheap, fast, objective and entirely silent on the question your customer cares about.
The panel is a judgement. It produces a verdict rather than a number, and it only produces a usable one when it is run blind against a known reference. There is no instrument for scent strength in a workshop and no published figure to compare against: CSI publishes no intensity rating, no throw measurement, no coverage area, no shelf life and no longevity figure for any oil, base, reed or bottle. The nearest published remark in the whole range is Pure Performance's page line, "performs well in Indian climates by balancing scent throw with longevity" — CSI's own words, and not a measurement.
That asymmetry is why the panel has to be engineered rather than improvised. A nose compares two things in the same minute reliably and compares across weeks very badly, so the reference has to be physically present at every reading. And it has to be a reference that has not itself drifted, which means a sealed twin from the original batch, opened once. A reference you keep reopening slowly becomes a second running bottle, at which point you are comparing two unknowns.
What each instrument settles · and what it must never be asked
The scale, the panel, and the inference that is not available
The scale
The blind panel
Cost
₹354, once
₹36 a sealed twin, one per reading
Output
Grams — a measurement
Same or different — a judgement
Reproducible by someone else?
Yes
Only as a verdict, and only blind
Answers
How much liquid is left, as a fraction of recorded net fill
Whether the bottle still smells like the batch did
Cannot answer
Anything about odour
Anything about quantity
Fails silently if
You skip the empty weight, so there is no net fill to divide
You reuse one reference, or anyone knows which glass is which
Needed for a claim
Yes
Yes — 2 of 2
Worked out above: the apparatus is small. One ₹354Candle Making Weighing Scale, kept for ever, plus one sealed twin per bottle per reading date at ₹36 each from a ₹360 pack of ten. A two-unit validation read on four dates needs 8 twins = ₹288, so one pack covers it with two spare. The scale also does the job that makes the whole thing possible at the bench: filling by mass, which is necessary because no density is published for any base or any oil, so there is no paper route between millilitres and grams. Hit the load by weight — oil = base weight ÷ 4 at 20%, ÷ 3 at 25%, × 3 ÷ 7 at the 30% maximum, all inside the published 10–30% window, with the published 24–48 hour rest before bottling. The panel mechanics in full — coding, randomising, how many noses, what to do with disagreements — are worked through in the coded blind screening post, so they are not restated here.
Four outcomes, and the one that looks fine
Crossing two instruments gives four outcomes, and they are not four shades of the same result — they are four different commercial situations with four different fixes. Naming which one you are in is most of the value of running the validation at all.
The outcome quadrant · liquid against odour at the claim date
What each combination means, what it looks like, and the fix it points at
Liquid
Odour
Name
What it looks like to a customer
Where the fix lives
Remains
"Same"
Pass · 2 of 2
Working product
Nothing. Repeat on a second unit and publish below the date
Remains
"Different, almost nothing"
The silent failure
A full bottle that does nothing — the worst review you will get
Load, base and oil choice. Not the fill size
Empty
Was "same" until the end
Liquid-limited
"It worked, then it ran out"
Reed count, fill size, placement guidance
Empty
"Different" before it emptied
Ordinary end
Faded, then finished
Publish a figure comfortably below the earlier of the two dates
Remains
Panel disagrees with itself
Unresolved
—
More noses, better coding, and check the twin has not drifted
Two units land in different quadrants
Spread as large as the effect
—
Add units before publishing anything at all
Worked out above, on the reader's own figures: suppose a 120 ml bottle at the published 25% ratio records a net fill of 120 g and, across weekly weighings, a loss of 1.3 g a day. At day 45 it has lost 45 × 1.3 = 58.5 g, so 61.5 g remain, which is 61.5 ÷ 120 = 51.3% of net fill. A weight-only check reads that as a comfortable pass with weeks to spare. If the panel at the same date says "different, almost nothing", you are in the heavy box — and a "lasts 45 days" claim built on the scale alone would be wrong on the day it was printed. Run the same arithmetic forward: at 1.3 g a day the bottle does not empty until day 92, so the gap between the liquid date and the odour date on that unit is enormous. The opposite case is just as real: a bottle losing 2.6 g a day off the same 120 g net fill empties on day 46, and if it was still judged "same" at day 42 then the claim date is the empty date and the fix is reed count or fill, not a different oil. Nothing in this paragraph comes from a CSI page — no net fill weight, consumption figure, evaporation rate or shelf life is published for anything in the range. The 120 g, the 1.3 and the 2.6 are figures the reader measures.
The mistake: validating a longevity claim with a scale alone because the scale is the only thing that produces a number. It is an entirely understandable mistake — grams feel like data and "smells fine" feels like an opinion, so the number wins and the opinion gets dropped. The result is a product that is signed off as lasting 45 days on the strength of a bottle that was half full and odourless on day 45. The fix is to make the judged column compulsory rather than optional: print the recording sheet with two columns side by side and a rule that a date with one column filled is an incomplete reading, not a partial pass. If nobody is available to run a panel on the day, the honest entry is "no panel — date not validated", and the claim date moves to the last date where both columns were filled.
1
Instrument one of two · answers exactly half the question
Candle Making Weighing Scale
₹354, 98 in stock. Bought once and used for ever, which makes it the cheapest line in any validation programme on a per-trial basis. Three jobs here. It fills by mass, which matters because no density is published for any base or oil and a fill line on glass is not a repeatable charge. It records the empty weight of every bottle before filling — the number everyone skips and then cannot recover, without which there is no net fill and therefore no percentage. And it produces the liquid-remaining column at every reading date, cap off and reeds in, at the same hour. What it cannot do is tell you anything about fragrance, and the discipline of this page is to stop asking it to. Pair it with the ₹354 Pen Thermometer — at 19 units, so thin — if you want the room temperature logged beside every reading, which any claim with a season attached to it needs.
Instrument two cannot work without this · ₹36 a reading
Attar Bottles ( 3ml, 6ml, 12 ml)
Three variants, all packs of ten: 3 ml ₹180, 6 ml ₹300, 12 ml ₹360 — so ₹18, ₹30 and ₹36 a bottle, with 99, 100 and 99 packs in stock. The 12 ml is the one to use: large enough for three or four noses at a sitting, small enough that eight of them cost ₹288. Fill them at bottling time from the same vessel as the running bottles, cap, tape, date and store cool — then open one per bottle per reading date, once. This is the cheapest sealed-reference vessel anywhere in the range and it is what converts an opinion into a verdict: without a physically present reference, a panel is comparing today's impression with a memory, which is the least reliable instrument in the building. Note a page inconsistency worth naming rather than resolving: the handle reads "2ml, 6ml, 12 ml" while the live listing is titled "Attar Bottles ( 3ml, 6ml, 12 ml)" and its variants are 3, 6 and 12 ml — there is no 2 ml.
Variant
Pack of 10
Per bottle
Eight reading pairs
12 ml
₹360
₹36.00
₹288, two spare
6 ml
₹300
₹30.00
₹240 — tight for a panel of four
3 ml
₹180
₹18.00
Too small to present properly
₹36 a sealed twin · the price of making the second column mean anythingBuy 12 ml attar bottles
Why the scale cannot answer the odour question
This section exists because the inference is so tempting that it gets made silently. If the bottle is 51% full, surely about 51% of the fragrance is still in there? No — and not approximately, not as a rule of thumb, and not with a correction factor. The honest position is stronger than "we do not know": the information required to make that inference is not published for anything in this range, so the inference is not available to anybody.
Here is the reasoning laid out. The liquid in the bottle is a mixture of base and fragrance oil. What leaves the bottle leaves from the exposed reed surface, and there is no reason the mixture leaving has to have the same proportions as the mixture remaining. If the fragrance leaves faster than the base, a half-full bottle holds less than half the original fragrance — possibly far less. If the base leaves faster, the reverse. Which of those happens, and by how much, is a property of your specific oil in your specific base, and CSI publishes no volatility, evaporation rate, viscosity, density or differential-loss figure for any base or any oil against which it could be computed. There is nothing to compute from, which is why the second instrument is not optional.
A second reason the scale cannot stand in: the two tracks can end in either order, and which order they end in is itself a finding. A bottle that fades long before it empties has a different fix from one that empties while still fragrant. If you only weigh, the two cases are indistinguishable — both are just "grams going down".
Four inferences people make from grams · and which survive
What the scale licenses and what it does not
Statement
Verdict
Reason
"It lost 58.5 g in 45 days, so 1.3 g a day in that room at that logged temperature"
Supported
Measured, dated, with the interval stated
"It is 51.3% full, so it is half way through its life"
Not supported
Life is bounded by whichever track ends first, and the odour track has no weight
"It is 51.3% full, so about half the fragrance remains"
Not available to anybody
No density, volatility or differential-loss data is published for any base or oil
"At 1.3 g a day it will last 92 days"
Arithmetic only
True as a division, and only if the rate holds and the odour track has not already ended
"It still weighs something, so the claim holds"
The silent failure
This is exactly the sentence that puts an odourless bottle on a label
"The four-week hot run says it will do 60 days"
Never
A bench run screens for change. No acceleration factor exists for this product — not published, not derivable, not a rule of thumb
Worked out above: 45 × 1.3 = 58.5 g lost; 120 − 58.5 = 61.5 g remaining; 61.5 ÷ 120 = 51.3%. The empty date by division is 120 ÷ 1.3 = 92.3 days, which is a division and not a prediction — it assumes the rate holds for another seven weeks, in a season you have not reached, and it says nothing at all about whether the bottle is still doing its job. That is the entire reason this page exists: the two numbers in that sentence, 92 days and 51.3% at day 45, are both true and both useless on their own. What makes them useful is the column beside them. For what a validated pair of dates lets you actually print — the wording, the assumptions that travel with it, and how many units it takes — the claims post owns that ground and is not repeated here.
A scale will never tell you the room has gone quiet. Print a number that two instruments agreed on, or print nothing.
— CandleMakingSuppliesIndia
Eight reading pairs: the build and the cadence
The unit of work in a validation is the reading pair — one date, one bottle, one weight and one blind verdict. Everything about the build follows from how many pairs you intend to produce, and the number is smaller than people fear.
1
Decide the claim date before you build anythingYou are validating a specific sentence, so write it down first: "45 days, in a non-air-conditioned Pune bedroom, eight reeds, 120 ml filled to a recorded net fill, May to June." The reading dates are then chosen around that date rather than scattered.
2
Build two units, not oneTwo bottles from one mix, filled by weight, eight reeds each from one pack, in the same room at the same height. Two is the minimum that lets you tell a result from an odd bottle; it is not a published standard and nothing on this page presents it as one.
3
Fill eight sealed twins at bottling timeFour per bottle, one for each reading date, each opened exactly once. ₹288 from a ₹360 pack of ten. Tape and date them, store them cool, and never let anyone "just check" one between dates.
4
Choose four reading dates that bracket the claimOne well before, one shortly before, one on the claim date and one after. The one on the claim date is the reading that matters; the one before tells you whether the failure was already arriving, and the one after tells you how much margin you had — which is what lets you publish a conservative figure rather than the edge.
5
Weigh weekly in between, and log the roomThe weekly weights give you the rate and let you see the claim date coming. Resolution is the reason for weekly rather than daily: a ±1 g scale error on a 1.3 g daily signal is around ±77%, while the same error on a 9.1 g week is about ±11%. Log the temperature at the bottle every time.
6
Run both instruments on the same day, in the same hourWeigh first, then open the twin, bring it to room temperature, present both coded and shuffled, and collect same-or-different from everyone you can find who has not been told which is which. Write the weight, the percentage, the date, the temperature and the verdict on one line.
7
Carry on past the claim date to the real endThis is the part that gets abandoned and it is where the quadrant is actually determined. Keep weighing and keep judging until the bottle is empty or until the panel has clearly gone to "different, almost nothing". Which of those happens first is the finding.
8
Publish below the earlier of the two ends, and per fragranceThe claim you may make is bounded by whichever track ended first, on the weaker of your two units, with its assumptions attached — room, season, airflow, reed count, fill. And it is validated for that fragrance: a range advertised across a collection needs each fragrance run separately.
The recording sheet · two columns that are both compulsory
What one reading pair looks like on the page
Entry
Example
Instrument
If it is blank
Unit
U1
—
You cannot tell your two units apart later
Date and day number
Day 45
—
Grams per day is uncomputable
Weight, cap off, reeds in
61.5 g
Scale
No liquid column; the reading is void
Liquid remaining
51.3% of a 120 g net fill
Scale
—
Room temperature at the bottle
33 °C
Thermometer
The rate cannot be interpreted or reproduced
Twin code opened
T-45-U1, first opening
Panel
The verdict has no reference and means nothing
Same or different
Different · 3 of 4 noses
Panel
The date is not validated — not partially passed
Sentence if different
"Much quieter, flatter"
Panel
"Different" alone cannot be acted on
Quadrant
Liquid remains · odour gone
Both
The whole point of the reading
Worked out above: 2 units × 4 reading dates = 8 reading pairs, so 8 weighings-with-a-panel and 8 sealed twins, plus roughly weekly weighings in between — across a 45-day claim with a run continuing past it, call it six to eight weeks of weekly weights on two bottles, which is 24 to 32 ordinary weighings taking under a minute each. Resolution arithmetic for the weekly cadence: on a 1.3 g a day signal, a ±1 g reading error is 1 ÷ 1.3 = ±76.9% of a day's loss, while across a week the loss is 9.1 g and the same error is 1 ÷ 9.1 = ±11.0%. That is the reason to divide across the longest interval you have rather than reading day to day — and the reason to write the interval next to every rate, since dividing a four-day gap by seven invents a slowdown that never happened. The full weighed-trial cadence, including the sixty-day case, is set out in the 60-day trial post, and how many replicate bottles your own spread justifies is in the replicates post.
What one reading pair costs
Dividing the bill by the number of reading pairs is the useful way to look at this, because it makes the real decision — how many dates and how many units — a priced one rather than a feeling.
3
The one-lot rung, and a ladder that falls all the way
Orchard Pear
₹105.02 / 15 gm, ₹240 / 50 gm, ₹380 / 100 gm, ₹1,870 / 500 gm, ₹3,738 / 1000 gm — so ₹7.00133, ₹4.80, ₹3.80, ₹3.74 and ₹3.738 a gram, falling at every single rung, with the kilo saving ₹2 against two 500 gm packs. For a two-unit validation you need 60 g, and both bottles must come from one pack because two units that differ in oil lot are not two units of the same product. The cheapest cash route to 60 g is a 50 gm plus a 15 gm at ₹345.02 for 65 g, but that is two lots; the one-lot buy is the 100 gm pack at ₹380, a ₹34.98 premium that also happens to be the better rate at ₹3.80/g against a blended ₹5.3080. At ₹3.80/g the oil in a 120 ml bottle at the published 25% ratio is ₹114.00. Nothing here says how this oil behaves late in a bottle's life or in heat — no volatility, evaporation rate or heat-stability statement is published for any oil in this range, and that absence is why the panel exists. One CSI buyer, Ranjita RAO, writes that it is "absolutely overwhelming fragrance" in a champagne candle; that is a candle observation and a first impression, not a late-life diffuser result. Its 500 gm inventory of 998 is placeholder-shaped; the 89, 92, 88 and 99 counts on the other rungs look real.
Cash out, consumed, and the cost of one reading pair
Two units, four reading dates, eight pairs
Line
Quantity
Pack bought
Cash out
Consumed
Bottles
2 × 120 ml
One 120 ML Pack of 10
₹1,062.00
₹212.40
Black fibre reeds
16
One Pack of 25
₹236.00
₹151.04
Base
180 ml
One 500 ml pack
₹1,099.00
₹395.64
Orchard Pear
60 g
One 100 gm
₹380.00
₹228.00
Sealed 12 ml twins
8
One pack of ten
₹360.00
₹288.00
Weighing scale
1
—
₹354.00
₹0 — kept
Total
—
—
₹3,491.00
₹1,275.08
Per reading pair
8 pairs
—
₹436.38
₹159.39
A fifth date on both units
2 more pairs
Two twins already in the pack
₹0
₹72.00
Worked out above: cash out 1,062 + 236 + 1,099 + 380 + 360 + 354 = ₹3,491.00. Consumed: glass 2 × ₹106.20 = ₹212.40; reeds 16 × ₹9.44 = ₹151.04 at the Pack of 25 rate; base 180 ml × ₹2.198 = ₹395.64; oil 60 × ₹3.80 = ₹228.00; twins 8 × ₹36 = ₹288.00 — total ₹1,275.08. Divided by eight reading pairs: ₹436.38 cash and ₹159.39 consumed each. One running bottle is 106.20 + 75.52 + 197.82 + 114.00 = ₹493.54 at the Pack of 25 reed rate, or ₹482.02 if you buy a Pack of 50 and pay the flat ₹8.00 — worth knowing, because a Pack of 50 is ₹164 dearer in cash while being ₹1.44 cheaper per reed, so for 16 reeds the small pack is the right buy. The cheapest extension is a fifth reading date: two more twins are already sitting in the ₹360 pack, so it costs ₹0 in cash and ₹72 in consumed glass. The expensive extension is a third unit at ₹493.54 of materials plus four more twins. And leftovers are substantial — eight bottles, nine reeds, 320 ml of base and 40 g of oil — so the repeat run on a second fragrance costs little more than its oil.
Add a date before you add a unit
In a validation, the extra date is nearly free and the extra unit is not. A fifth reading date costs ₹0 in cash because the twins are already in the pack; a third bottle costs ₹493.54 of materials. Dates sharpen when the quadrant changed, which is the commercially useful question — the day the room went quiet. Units sharpen whether the result is real, which only matters once you have seen a result at all. So read more often first, and buy the third bottle when two units disagree.
The slower base can manufacture the silent failure
There is one more reason to insist on both instruments, and it is the commonest route into the heavy box. When a bottle empties too fast in summer, the obvious move is to reach for a base that holds the liquid longer. That move is reasonable and it has a specific risk: a slower-evaporating base is not automatically a better base. If it restricts wicking or fragrance release, the diffuser lasts longer and smells of less — which is to say it converts a liquid problem into an odour problem, and the scale will applaud.
What CSI actually publishes about this, quotable as CSI's own words and not as measurements: Depth is the only base in the range whose page claims to "slow evaporation" and to "stabilise tricky sweet and spicy fragrance oils", and Longevity the only one claiming "extended cold diffusion" and performance "without fading too fast". Those are page claims; they are not numbers and they cannot rank two bases. And the pricing makes the temptation worse rather than better, which is worth saying plainly.
4
The slower base costs ₹0 more · which is exactly why it needs two readings
Depth Base — Professional Reed & Car Diffuser Base (500 ml)
₹1,099 per 500 ml, so ₹2.198 a millilitre — identical to Pure Performance, Lift and Softness. So switching to the one base whose page says it "slows evaporation" adds ₹0 a bottle, which removes the one natural brake on making the swap: a free change gets made without being tested. Only Longevity at ₹1,296 is dearer — ₹0.394/ml, which is ₹35.46 a bottle at the published 25% ratio. Published on the page: the 10–30% blend window, a 25–30% working ratio, a 24–48 hour rest. Two things to name and not resolve: its details table says "70-75% Depth Base with 25-30% fragrance oil" while its own dose cards mark 20% as "Recommended"; and the fibre reed pages' base-compatibility list names Pure Performance, Lift, Longevity and Softness and omits Depth, with one instance saying "including" — page copy that reads as not updated rather than a statement of incompatibility. One more thing to check before reaching for it: Depth's page lists "Fresh citrus, light florals, aquatics" under Avoid and routes them to Lift, so on a citrus or aquatic formula the slow-evaporation base is the one CSI's own copy steers away from. Stock 982, which is plausible rather than placeholder-shaped.
Base
500 ml
Per ml
Per bottle at 25%
Depth
₹1,099
₹2.198
₹197.82 — ₹0 premium
Pure Performance / Lift / Softness
₹1,099
₹2.198
₹197.82
Longevity
₹1,296
₹2.592
₹233.28 — ₹35.46 more
At 10 / 20 / 30% on Longevity
₹42.55 · ₹37.82 · ₹33.10 premium a bottle
₹197.82 of base per 120 ml bottle at the published 25% ratioBuy Depth base
One base swap, two readings · the only honest way to score it
What each combination of outcomes means for the swap
Consumption after the swap
Judged throw after the swap
Verdict on the swap
Lower grams per day
Judged "same" as before
Keep it. Longer life at no cost in throw
Lower grams per day
Judged quieter
Reject or re-load. You bought days with throw — the silent failure, created on purpose
Unchanged grams per day
Judged quieter
Reject. All cost, no benefit
Unchanged
Unchanged
No effect in your system. Keep whichever is cheaper — and four of the five are the same price
Higher grams per day
Judged stronger
A throw decision, not a longevity one. Price it per bottle before deciding
Any
Any
Never judge a base swap on days alone. That is the one reading that cannot see the failure mode
Worked out above: the money on a base swap between the four ₹1,099 bases is ₹0 a bottle, and on Longevity it is ₹35.46 at the published 25% ratio (90 ml × ₹0.394), or ₹42.55, ₹37.82 and ₹33.10 at 10, 20 and the 30% ceiling. Against the running cost of a bottle at ₹493.54, a Longevity swap is 7.2% more expensive — which is a small number next to the cost of being wrong about a published claim. Also note the one-off nature of the test against the permanent nature of a hardware change: a reformulation test is paid once, while a decision to run two reed sets inside one burn window takes a 120 ml bottle's hardware from ₹170.20 to ₹234.20, a 37.6% permanent increase. That asymmetry is the cleanest argument there is for testing one variable properly rather than changing two things and hoping. For the oil-side version of this question — whether a different oil rather than a different base is the lever — the plain-base blank post separates carrier loss from fragrance contribution, and the reeded-against-bare comparison isolates the reed surface.
The CSI principle
Weigh it and smell it blind on the same day. A claim passes when both pass, and a bottle that is half full and odourless has failed no matter what the scale says.
We publish no shelf life, no longevity figure, no evaporation rate, no density and no intensity rating for any base, oil, reed or bottle — so there is nothing here from which fragrance remaining could be inferred from grams remaining, by us or by anybody. What we can price is the apparatus: ₹354 for the first instrument, ₹36 a sealed twin for the second, and ₹436.38 of cash out per reading pair.
Why trust this guide
CANDLEMAKINGSUPPLIESINDIA supplies raw materials, not finished diffusers. No oil or base on this page is described as holding its throw late in life, because nobody at this end has smelled your blend in your base at your load in your room, and because we publish no intensity rating, evaporation rate, volatility or heat-stability statement for anything. We would sell more base by telling you that the slow one fixes summer. Instead this page says that the slow one is free, which is exactly why it gets swapped in untested, and that the failure it can create — a full bottle in a silent room — is invisible to the only instrument most people use.
Prices, packs, stock and stated specifications come from live CSI data in October 2026 and link to the product page, where current pricing always takes precedence. Availability was checked per variant, which is why Orchard Pear's 998-pack 500 gm count is named as placeholder-shaped rather than quoted as depth, and why the Pen Thermometer's 19 units are named as thin. Quoted as published: the 10–30% blend window, the 25–30% working ratio and the 24–48 hour rest; 20.3 cm reed length, counts of 4–5 / 6–8 / 10+ with 6–8 named for a 50–100 ml bottle, a 3–5 day flip, 1–2 hours initial absorption, "uniform pore structure — no swelling, no clogging, no splitting", "consistent diffusion from day 1 to day 30", "avoid placing in direct sunlight or near heat sources which accelerate evaporation" and "place near a doorway or gentle air movement"; Pure Performance's "performs well in Indian climates by balancing scent throw with longevity"; Depth's "slows evaporation", "stabilises tricky sweet and spicy fragrance oils" and its Avoid list of "Fresh citrus, light florals, aquatics"; Longevity's "extended cold diffusion" and "without fading too fast". Named and not resolved: Depth's details table saying 70–75% base with 25–30% oil against its own dose cards marking 20% "Recommended"; the fibre reeds' base-compatibility list omitting Depth; the attar bottle handle reading "2ml" when no 2 ml variant exists; and the bottle page's "Size: 50 and 100ml" body copy against its 50/120 ML variants.
Blend percentages are formulation windows, not safety limits. Supplier documentation — including documentation certified or approved by IFRA — is available on request and is yours to read rather than ours to summarise; compliance, labelling and any published claim belong with a qualified adviser in your market. For the validation kit, bulk pricing, GST invoicing or documentation, message us on WhatsApp at +91 7397976926.
Frequently asked questions
If the bottle is half full, is half the fragrance still in it?
That inference is not available — not to us, not to you, not with a correction factor. The liquid is a mixture of base and oil, what leaves does so from the exposed reed surface, and there is no reason the mixture leaving has the same proportions as the mixture remaining. Whether the fragrance goes faster than the base, and by how much, is a property of your specific oil in your specific base, and CSI publishes no density, volatility, evaporation rate or differential-loss figure for any base or oil from which it could be computed. So the scale answers the quantity question and nothing else. The odour question needs the second instrument: a blind comparison against a sealed 12 ml twin from the same batch, at ₹36 from a ₹360 pack of ten.
What exactly is the failure mode I should be looking for?
Liquid present, odour gone. A bottle that is still half full on the claim date and smells of almost nothing. It is the worst of the four outcomes commercially for two reasons: the customer is holding visible proof that the product has not "run out", so they conclude it was faulty rather than finished; and it passes any check that only weighs, so it reaches a label unchallenged. On the reader's own figures a 120 g net fill losing 1.3 g a day is 51.3% full at day 45 and would not empty until around day 92 — so weight alone would read that bottle as having seven weeks of life left while the room had already gone quiet. Name it on the recording sheet as its own quadrant so it cannot be mistaken for a pass.
How many reading dates and how many bottles do I need?
Four dates and two bottles is a defensible minimum and is not a published standard — eight reading pairs, each one weight plus one coded verdict. Put one date well before the claim, one shortly before, one on the claim date and one after it, so you can publish a figure with margin rather than at the edge. Two bottles rather than one because a single odd unit otherwise becomes your result. Then grow in the cheap direction: a fifth date costs ₹0 in cash, since the twins are already in the ₹360 pack of ten, while a third bottle costs ₹493.54 of materials. How many units a published figure needs, and the wording that goes with it, is covered in the claims post.
Can I run the panel a few days after the weighing if nobody is around?
No, and the honest entry when that happens is "no panel — date not validated". The two readings have to describe the same bottle in the same state, and a reed diffuser changes between Friday and Tuesday. A date with only the weight filled in is an incomplete reading rather than a partial pass, and your claim date then moves back to the last date where both columns were filled. Build the sheet with the two columns side by side so the gap is visible, and schedule the reading dates when you know somebody will be there — the panel does not need experts, only people who have not been told which glass is which.
Would a slower base make my claim easier to validate?
It may make it harder, by moving you into the silent failure. A slower-evaporating base is not automatically a better base: if it restricts wicking or fragrance release, the bottle lasts longer and smells of less, which is the one outcome a weight-only check cannot see. And the price structure removes the usual brake — Depth, the only base whose page claims to "slow evaporation", is ₹1,099 per 500 ml, exactly the same as Pure Performance, Lift and Softness, so the swap costs ₹0 a bottle and gets made without a test. Score any swap on both readings. And if your formula is a citrus or an aquatic, Depth's own page lists those under Avoid and points to Lift.
Can I validate a 45-day claim with a four-week hot-cupboard run?
No. A warm or hot bench run screens for change — cloudiness, separation, sediment, colour movement, a coded odour difference against a cool reference — and it is never evidence that a finished product will perform for a stated number of days in a customer's home. There is no acceleration factor for this product: not published, not derivable, and not worth repeating as a rule of thumb. CSI publishes no temperature data of any kind for any base, oil, reed or bottle, so there is nothing to convert from even if a conversion existed. A 45-day claim is validated by two instruments agreeing on day 45, on more than one unit, in the condition most of your customers are in — and by then running on past it, because which of the two tracks ends first is the finding.
Two columns, same date, both compulsory
₹3,491 cash out, ₹1,275.08 consumed — ₹436.38 a reading pair, and the fifth date is free.
Candle Making Weighing Scale ₹354 (98 in stock); Pen Thermometer ₹354 (19). Attar Bottles 3 ml ₹180, 6 ml ₹300, 12 ml ₹360, all packs of ten — so ₹36 a sealed twin. Gold Reed Diffuser Bottles ₹826 per ten 50 ML and ₹1,062 per ten 120 ML, no 100 ml or 200 ml variant listed. Black fibre reeds ₹236 / 25, ₹400 / 50, ₹800 / 100, ₹4,000 / 500; white ₹265 / ₹450 / ₹900 / ₹4,500. Depth, Pure Performance, Lift and Softness ₹1,099 / 500 ml; Pure Performance also ₹325 / 100 g; Longevity ₹1,296. Orchard Pear ₹105.02 / 15 gm, ₹240 / 50 gm, ₹380 / 100 gm, ₹1,870 / 500 gm, ₹3,738 / 1000 gm. Tell us the claim you want to validate and we will price the units and the reference glass.
About this guide: Written by the CANDLEMAKINGSUPPLIESINDIA team. The two-instrument rule, the outcome quadrant, the reading-pair unit, the one-twin-per-reading discipline and the swap-scoring table apply to any supplier's materials.
Customer reviews: The ten reviews above are genuine published Judge.me reviews from CSI product pages, unedited. Each is a single early impression on one instrument, with no weight, no reference and no second unit, so none validates a longevity claim; most are candle observations rather than diffuser ones.
Figures verified October 2026: Candle Making Weighing Scale ₹354 (98); Pen Thermometer ₹354 (19); Attar Bottles 3 ml ₹180 (99), 6 ml ₹300 (100), 12 ml ₹360 (99), all packs of ten; Gold Reed Diffuser Bottles ₹826 / ten 50 ML (16 packs) and ₹1,062 / ten 120 ML (24); black fibre reeds ₹236 / ₹400 / ₹800 / ₹4,000 at 73 / 93 / 95 / 100 packs and white ₹265 / ₹450 / ₹900 / ₹4,500; Depth ₹1,099 (982), Pure Performance ₹325 / 100 g (63) and ₹1,099 / 500 ML (56), Lift ₹1,099 (66), Softness ₹1,099 (98), Longevity ₹1,296 (40); Orchard Pear ₹105.02 / 15 gm (89), ₹240 / 50 gm (92), ₹380 / 100 gm (88), ₹1,870 / 500 gm (998 — placeholder-shaped), ₹3,738 / 1000 gm (99). Derived here: ₹106.20 and ₹82.60 a bottle, ₹36 a sealed twin; reeds ₹9.44 at the Pack of 25 then flat ₹8.00, so 16 reeds cost ₹236 in cash from the small pack against ₹400 from the Pack of 50 — ₹164 less in cash while ₹1.44 dearer a reed; base ₹2.198/ml and ₹2.592/ml, so ₹197.82 and ₹233.28 per 120 ml bottle at the published 25% ratio and a Longevity premium of ₹42.55 / ₹37.82 / ₹35.46 / ₹33.10 at 10 / 20 / 25 / 30%; Orchard Pear ₹7.00133, ₹4.80, ₹3.80, ₹3.74 and ₹3.738 a gram with the kilo saving ₹2, 60 g costing ₹380 from one lot against ₹345.02 from two — a ₹34.98 premium at a better rate of ₹3.80 against a blended ₹5.3080; oil ₹114.00 a bottle; one running bottle ₹493.54 at the ₹9.44 reed rate or ₹482.02 at ₹8.00; cash out ₹3,491.00 and consumed ₹1,275.08, so ₹436.38 and ₹159.39 per reading pair; a fifth date ₹0 cash and ₹72 consumed; two reed sets in one window taking hardware from ₹170.20 to ₹234.20, a 37.6% rise; a Longevity swap at 7.2% of a bottle's cost. Reader-supplied illustrations: a 120 g net fill losing 1.3 g a day is 58.5 g lost and 61.5 g left at day 45, so 51.3%, emptying around day 92; at 2.6 g a day the same fill empties on day 46; resolution ±1 g is ±76.9% of a 1.3 g day and ±11.0% of a 9.1 g week. Not published anywhere in this range and therefore not claimed here: no shelf life, longevity figure, intensity rating, throw measurement, coverage area, evaporation rate, volatility, viscosity, density, differential-loss figure, storage temperature or heat-stability statement for any base, oil, reed or bottle; no reed diameter, pore size or fibre count; no bottle neck diameter. Consequently no oil or base here is described as holding its throw, and none is ranked. Every weight, rate, temperature and day-count in the protocol is the reader's own. Prices and availability change — the linked product pages are always authoritative.