I Made Three Reed Diffusers Using DPG, DPM and an Augeo-Type Base at 20% Fragrance — How Do I Compare Them Using the Same Bottle and Reeds?
Aktie
What must be identical? Bottle model, reed pack and count, fill by weight, oil lot, mixing order, rest time, shelf, flipping policy and scale. Only the carrier changes.
How do I score them? Three gates first: clear throughout, three bottles in agreement, release inside your grams-a-day band. Then a weighted blind throw score. An arm that fails a gate isn't scored, however good it smells.
What does CSI supply? Not DPG, DPM or Augeo-type solvents. For the test: bottles, reeds, a scale, a test oil and an optional base arm; ₹2,743.80 for oil, base arm and reeds with your own bottles.
- Straight answer: how to compare three carriers fairly
- What your three bottles can and can't tell you
- "Same bottle and reeds": the full held-constant list
- The cause table: why arms differ, and which differences are real
- The three-arm protocol, with an optional base arm
- The scoring sheet, and a worked illustrative result
- After the score: cost, documents and the purchase step
- What to buy for the comparison, and what to skip
- Frequently asked questions
What your three bottles can and can't tell you
Your three diffusers are useful, just not as a verdict. Each carrier has one bottle, so a faster or stronger bottle could reflect its carrier, or its neck, or a reed that wicks better, or a fill that sits higher, or the warm afternoon it was mixed. With one bottle per arm you can't tell those apart, and makers who choose a carrier on that basis often find the "winner" doesn't repeat.
What the pilot can do is set your expectations and your band. Weigh each of the three now, again in three days, and note grams a day. Note which is clear, which smells of the carrier as well as the fragrance, and which reeds look wet or dry at the tips. You now know roughly where each carrier sits, and you can set a grams-a-day band from the product life you plan to sell: 90 g usable over 30–45 days is about 2–3 g a day. Write that band down before the real run starts.
One more use for the pilot: smell each carrier alone. Dip a clean blotter in each, code them, and sniff blind at 1 hour and 24 hours. A carrier with an odour you would notice under the fragrance is flagged before it costs you oil; the full method is the carrier-odour post.
"Same bottle and reeds": the full held-constant list
Your question names the two most visible constants. A fair comparison needs eight, because each of these, changed between arms, can move grams a day or blind scores as much as a carrier swap. The diagram shows them on the bench; the table gives the reason and the method for each.
| What | Hold it at | Why it matters | How |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bottle | One model, one batch; same neck and cap | The neck meters evaporation; a different neck is a different test | Gold 120 ML, or twelve of your own |
| Reeds | One pack, six per bottle, 20.3 cm, uncut | Reed count and length change release more than many carrier swaps | Handle by the dry end; record the pack |
| Fill | 100 g by weight, not to a line | Carriers differ in density; equal ml are unequal grams | Tare, fill, wipe, weigh |
| Oil | One lot, 20 g per 100 g | A second lot is a second variable | Mix all masters from one bottle |
| Process | Carrier first, then oil; same stir; same 24–48 h rest | Order and rest change early clarity and early throw | One written procedure |
| Room | One shelf, rotated at every reading | Position near a door or window favours one arm | Log temperature and humidity |
| Flipping | None until day 30 (or all at once) | A flip spikes the arm you flipped | Write the policy down |
| Measurement | One scale, same time of day; blind codes | Open sniffing finds the arm you expect | Helper holds the key |
Two rows are easy to get wrong. Flipping: the reed page says "Flip every 3-5 days", which is good advice for a customer and bad practice for a comparison, because the arm you flip spikes on the day you flip it. Either flip nothing until day 30, or flip every bottle at the same moment, after the reading. Fill: DPG, DPM and an Augeo-type solvent don't have the same density, so 100 ml of each is not 100 g; weigh, never pour to a line. The same discipline at production scale is in the 20-bottle consistency post.
The cause table: why arms differ, and which differences are real
Rows separate the carrier itself from the oil, the reed and bottle, the room, the process and measurement. Each discriminating check changes one thing. This describes what makers commonly report, not CSI test data.
| Cause | What you would see | Discriminating check | Fix |
|---|---|---|---|
| Solvent volatility | One arm loses weight much faster or slower than the others | Median grams a day per arm, three bottles each | Choose on band and throw together, never on weight loss alone |
| Solubility and stability | Haze, droplets or a layer in one carrier | The 20 g jar of that carrier, room and cool, 7 days | That carrier is out at 20% with this oil |
| Fragrance load and oil character | Every arm faint, or every arm loses its top notes by day 14 | A second oil in the best two arms | The oil is the limit; change it before the carrier |
| Reed, bottle and fill | Bottles inside one arm disagree by more than about ±20% | Check reed count, depth, fill weight and neck | Re-run that arm; don't read it |
| Environment | All arms jump or fall on the same day | Your temperature and humidity log | Compare arms on the same day only |
| Process | One arm made on a different day, stirred or rested differently | Batch log | Make every master in one session |
| Measurement error | Scores follow the bottle you knew; weights drift by the hour | Blind codes; repeat weighing of one bottle five times | Fix the method before reading results |
The solvent row needs one warning. Faster weight loss is not stronger throw. A more volatile carrier can leave the reed faster than the fragrance does, so an arm can lose weight quickly and smell only a little stronger. That pattern is the subject of the faster-but-not-stronger post; here it simply means you never choose on weight loss alone.
The three-arm protocol, with an optional base arm
Each arm is a master of 256 g of carrier with the matching oil: three 100 g bottles and a 20 g jar for the clarity check. Mix all masters in one session from one oil bottle. The optional fourth arm uses a ready-made base exactly as the solvents are used.
| Arm | Per 100 g bottle | Codes (example) | Role |
|---|---|---|---|
| A · DPG | 20 g oil + 80 g DPG | 02 · 07 · 11 | The slow benchmark and control |
| B · DPM | 20 g oil + 80 g DPM | 04 · 09 · 12 | Generally more volatile and thinner |
| C · Augeo-type | 20 g oil + 80 g Augeo-type solvent | 01 · 06 · 10 | A solvent class marketed for diffusers |
| D · CSI base (optional) | 20 g oil + 80 g Pure Performance | 03 · 05 · 08 | A black-box ready-made arm |
A log template with room columns and a reed-condition column is in our live guide on testing reed diffuser performance over 30 days; if any jar or bottle clouds, the cloudy-mixing guide covers the diagnosis. If you have only two carriers to compare, the simpler two-arm version is the DPG-versus-base comparison post.
The scoring sheet, and a worked illustrative result
Here is how a finished sheet might look. The numbers are illustrative, made up to show the method, not CSI test data and not a prediction of how DPG, DPM, an Augeo-type solvent or our base will behave with your oil. Grams a day are medians of three bottles; "throw" is the mean blind score at 1 m / at the door; life is 90 g usable divided by grams a day.
| Arm | g/day | Life (days) | Spread | Clarity | Throw 1 m / door | Character d28 | Gates | Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A · DPG | 1.1 | about 82 | ±12% | clear | 1.8 / 1.0 | 3.5 | below band | 1.98 |
| B · DPM | 3.4 | about 26 | ±15% | clear | 3.4 / 2.5 | 2.5 | above band | 3.04 |
| C · Augeo-type | 2.4 | about 38 | ±10% | clear | 3.3 / 2.3 | 3.5 | passes | 3.14 |
| D · CSI base | 2.2 | about 41 | ±28% | clear | 3.0 / 2.0 | 3.5 | agreement fails: re-run | 2.90 |
Reading the example: the DPG arm is clear and steady but below the band and faint, the pattern the series opens with. The DPM arm throws well but runs above the band, about 26 days of product, and loses character by day 28, a hint that it leaves faster than parts of the fragrance; it fails gate 3 and is not ranked, but it points to a DPG/DPM ratio trial. The Augeo-type arm passes every gate and scores 3.14. The CSI base arm scores 2.90 but its three bottles disagree by ±28%, so it fails gate 2 and is re-run before anyone reads it, which in the example might reverse the order or might not. Scores are printed for every arm so you can see the arithmetic; only arms through all three gates are ranked.
Notice what the sheet stops you doing: choosing DPM for its throw while ignoring a bottle that would empty in under a month, or choosing the base because it is the one you bought. Whether a faster-emptying, better-throwing arm is the better commercial product is a separate question with its own maths: the throw-versus-life post. If you want the full selection system with cost and stability weights, it is the controlled-tests selection post.
After the score: cost, documents and the purchase step
Carrier cost per bottle comes from your invoices: 80 g × your price per kg ÷ 1,000 for each solvent. The CSI side is published. Fresh Strawberries at 20 g is ₹75.60 a bottle from the 100 gm and ₹70.80 at the 1 kg price; Pure Performance is ₹260.00 for 80 g from the 100g and ₹175.84 for 80 ml from the 500 ML, if your weighed density is near 1.0 g/ml. Before you scale any winner, hold its SDS: flammability, hazard labelling and transport depend on the full formula, and a more volatile carrier generally needs more care. That question has its own post in the blend cluster; here, the rule is simply no SDS, no scale-up.
Say the winner goes into a first run of 60 bottles: 1,200 g of oil and 4,800 g of carrier. Oil: a 1 kg plus two 100 gm (₹4,295.20), which costs ₹1,014.80 less than a 1 kg plus a 500 gm and leaves nothing over. Reeds: 360, as three packs of 100 plus a 50 and a 25 (₹3,036.00). Bottles: six Gold 120 ML packs (₹6,372.00). If one of your solvents won, the CSI side is ₹13,703.20. If the CSI base won, add ten Pure Performance 500 ML (₹10,990.00) for 5,000 ml: ₹24,693.20. Material costs exclude labour, freight, packaging and GST.
What we don't sell, and what our pages don't say. CSI does not list DPG, DPM, IPM, Augeo-type solvents or perfumer's alcohol; Augeo is a brand name of Solvay, another company's trademark, and "Augeo-type" describes the solvent class. The only alcohol in our catalogue is an Isopropyl Alcohol Spray, a cleaner, never a diffuser ingredient. Every in-stock CSI base page says "Blend with 10-30% fragrance oil", but none states its composition, density, flash point, SDS or IFRA information in the text we captured, so we never claim our base contains or excludes any of your three solvents, and never claim it always outperforms them.
Safety, plainly. Treat every arm as flammable until its SDS says otherwise; a more volatile carrier generally needs more care. Mix and store away from flames, hobs and heaters, and keep test bottles away from candles. Wear gloves and eye protection; wash skin contact off with soap and water. Keep raw materials and test bottles out of reach of children and pets, and wipe drips from varnished shelves at once. Labelling and courier rules depend on the full formula and where you sell; read every SDS and take advice. This is not legal advice.
What to buy for the comparison, and what to skip
Chosen on page statements, price and stock on 7 October 2026, not on performance data; CSI publishes none for its bases, reeds or bottles. Each card says when not to buy.
| Variant | Price | Each | For this test |
|---|---|---|---|
| 120 ML Pack of 10 | ₹1,062.00 | ₹106.20 each | two packs (₹2,124.00) for 12 bottles; one pack covers three arms |
| 50 ML Pack of 10 | ₹826.00 | ₹82.60 each | only if you sell 50 ml |
| Pack | Price | Per reed | For this test |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pack of 25 | ₹236.00 | ₹9.44 | with the 50 |
| Pack of 50 | ₹400.00 | ₹8.00 | with the 25: 72 needed, 3 spare |
| Pack of 100 | ₹800.00 | ₹8.00 | same per reed as the 50 |
| Pack of 500 | ₹4,000.00 | ₹8.00 | production only |
| Item | Price | Units | Check |
|---|---|---|---|
| One scale | ₹354.00 | grams or ounces (page) | resolution not stated: check it shows 0.1 g |
| Size | Price | Per gram | Use |
|---|---|---|---|
| 15 gm | ₹113.28 | ₹7.55 | smell check only |
| 50 gm | ₹212.40 | ₹4.25 | two bottles |
| 100 gm | ₹377.60 | ₹3.78 | three cover 256 g, 44 g spare |
| 500 gm | ₹1,770.00 | ₹3.54 | ₹637.20 more than three 100 gm |
| 1 kg | ₹3,540.00 | ₹3.54 | the 60-bottle run, with two 100 gm |
| Size | Price | Unit price | For this test |
|---|---|---|---|
| 100g | ₹325.00 | ₹3.25 a gram | three: 256 g needed, 44 g spare |
| 500 ML | ₹1,099.00 | ₹2.20 a ml | ₹124.00 more than three 100g; for production |
Skip for now: a second CSI base (one ready-made arm answers the black-box question); the CSI HyperDiffusion Base™, out of stock on 7 October 2026; the Room & Linen Spray Base and the Ultrasonic Diffusion Concentrate Base™, which are not reed diffuser bases; the 500 reed pack, the same price per reed as the 50; and any production pack before a second run. With bottles and the scale, the whole bench is ₹5,221.80.
CandleMakingSuppliesIndia sells the bottles, reeds, scale, oil and base named here. It does not sell DPG, DPM, IPM, Augeo-type solvents or perfumer's alcohol, and this page says so. Our base is an optional arm, and the page tells you to keep your own solvent if it wins.
Every CSI price was checked on 7 October 2026, with stock checked per variant; everything priced here was in stock on that date, and the CSI HyperDiffusion Base™ is out of stock and not offered. Page wording is quoted and attributed to the page.
Solvent behaviour is described as general, hedged tendencies with no numeric flash points, viscosities, densities or evaporation rates. The results table is illustrative and labelled as such; the band, gates, weights and 60-bottle run are worked examples; nothing here is CSI test data. For bulk pricing, GST invoicing, and MSDS and IFRA documentation for our fragrance oils on request, message us on WhatsApp at +91 7397976926.
Frequently asked questions
- I Have DPG, DPM and IPM in My Workshop — Which One Should I Test First as a Reed Diffuser Carrier, and What Properties Should Guide the Choice?
- I Want to Make a Reed Diffuser Using DPM Instead of DPG — What Differences in Wicking, Fragrance Solubility and Evaporation Should I Measure?
- My Augeo-Type Base Produces Better Throw Than DPG but Consumes Liquid Faster — How Do I Decide Which Formula Is Better for a Commercial Product?
- I Bought an Augeo-Type Reed Diffuser Base, but My Vanilla Fragrance Turns Cloudy at 25% — Should I Test a Lower Load or Different Base?
- I Want to Compare DPM and an Augeo-Type Solvent for a Lavender Reed Diffuser — How Do I Set Up a 100 g Side-by-Side Trial?
- I Made a Reed Diffuser with 20% Sandalwood Fragrance Oil and an Augeo-Type Base, but the Reeds Wick Slowly — What Should I Investigate?
- I Have Two Commercial Reed Diffuser Bases with Different Solvent Compositions — How Do I Compare Their Performance Without Knowing Every Proprietary Ingredient?
- How Do I Choose Between DPG, DPM, IPM and an Augeo-Type Reed Diffuser Base Using Controlled Tests for Solubility, Wicking, Throw, Evaporation, Stability and Cost?
Customer reviews: The six reviews at the top of this page are genuine, published Judge.me reviews left by CSI customers on the product pages named on each card — Cinnamon Vanilla, Fresh Strawberries, Gold Reed Diffuser Bottle Pack of 10 (50 ML and 120 ML), Lift Base – Professional Grade Reed & Car Diffuser Base (500 ml), Orchard Pear. They are general product reviews, not assessments of the reed-diffuser formulation advice on this page. Names, star ratings, dates and products are as recorded by Judge.me and wording is unedited. "Verified buyer" appears only on reviews Judge.me recorded as verified — Uchu Omoide, snehal Chaudhary, Sooraj R, Ranjita RAO, Punam Sarma. The reviews from Kavitha murthy are published but not recorded as verified, and carry no badge. Reviews below five stars are included as published, not filtered out.
Figures verified 7 October 2026, CSI live pricing: Gold Reed Diffuser Bottle Pack of 10, 120 ML ₹1,062.00 (₹106.20 each), 50 ML ₹826.00 (₹82.60 each); Fiber Diffuser Reeds (Black) 25 ₹236.00 (₹9.44 a reed), 50 ₹400.00, 100 ₹800.00, 500 ₹4,000.00 (₹8.00 a reed from 50 up); Candle Making Weighing Scale ₹354.00; Fresh Strawberries 15 gm ₹113.28 (₹7.55 a gram), 50 gm ₹212.40 (₹4.25 a gram), 100 gm ₹377.60 (₹3.78 a gram), 500 gm ₹1,770.00 (₹3.54 a gram), 1 kg ₹3,540.00 (₹3.54 a gram); Pure Performance Reed Base Oil 100g ₹325.00, 500 ML ₹1,099.00 (₹2.20 a ml); CSI HyperDiffusion Base™ ₹1,499.00 (out of stock). Per unit = pack price ÷ units, two decimals. CSI does not list DPG, DPM, IPM, Augeo-type solvents or perfumer's alcohol.
Non-price figures: the three carriers and 20% load are the reader's; 20 g + 80 g per 100 g, six reeds, codes, band, gates, weights and the 60-bottle run are labelled worked examples. The results table (grams a day, spreads, scores, lives) is illustrative, not CSI test data. Solvent properties are general tendencies; no numeric viscosities, densities, flash points or evaporation rates are quoted. "6-8 reeds gives a good balance", "Flip every 3-5 days", "no swelling, no clogging", "Consistent diffusion from day 1 to day 30", "grams or ounces", "Blend with 10-30% fragrance oil" and "For reed diffusers, use 10-30%" are page wording. Augeo is a trademark of Solvay. Costs exclude labour, freight, packaging and GST. Diwali 8 November 2026 and Christmas 25 December 2026 are calendar facts.