Should a New Candle Business Buy Ten 100 g Fragrance Samples First or Immediately Buy 1 Kg Each of a Few Popular Scents?

The two baskets, side by side

Set both out in full before arguing about either. The sample basket below is ten in-stock CSI oils at the 100 g rung, chosen to span citrus, floral, gourmand, woody, herbal and tropical directions. The kilo basket is three of the same oils at the largest listed pack. Both are priced from live listings, and both candle counts use the same conversion: 14.8 g of oil per 200 g-class candle at 8% of a 185 g wax fill.

The honest case for Basket B is in the fifth column: ₹58.62 of spend per candle against ₹76.10, a genuine ₹17.48 advantage, and 141 more candles. If you knew those three scents would sell, Basket B would be the obvious buy. The question is whether you know, and on a first order the answer is no — which turns the sixth column from a footnote into the headline. ₹10,735.57 of stranded oil is more than twice the entire cost of Basket A, and it buys nothing except a long conversation with yourself about wax melts.

Is the kilo actually cheaper? Checked, oil by oil

This is the step almost everyone skips, and on this store it is not optional. Ten 100 g bottles and one kilo are the same 1,000 g, so the comparison is exact: just divide. The table does it for every oil in Basket A.

Six of ten reward the kilo, three are a dead heat and one punishes it. More to the point, look at the distribution of the reward: it is almost entirely one oil. Citronella alone accounts for ₹4,779 of the ₹6,135 net saving available across all ten — the other nine put together are worth ₹1,356. If you buy kilos indiscriminately because "bulk is cheaper", you are generalising from one listing to ten.

And the pattern gets worse outside this basket. Sage and Cedarwood lists 500 gm at ₹2,584.20 and 1 kg at ₹6,867.60, so two 500 g bottles supply the identical 1,000 g for ₹5,168.40 — the kilo is ₹1,699.20 dearer, a 32.9% penalty for buying the larger pack. There is no rule on this store that bigger is cheaper, within a family or across the range. The only reliable method is to divide the two prices on the oil in front of you, before every order.

How many candles of one scent a kilo needs before it pays

A per-gram comparison assumes you use the whole bottle. You will not, at first — so the useful question is different: at what point does a kilo stop being the more expensive decision? Divide the kilo price by the 100 g price per gram and you get the grams you must consume before the two routes cost the same. Below that point, buying samples as you go was cheaper.

Read that column of candle counts as the question the kilo is really asking you: am I confident of selling 58 to 67 candles of this one scent? For a business with no sales history, the honest answer is that you have no idea — and for four of these ten oils the kilo cannot win even if the answer is yes, because the price per gram does not fall. Citronella is the single genuine exception, and it is instructive precisely because it is so extreme: its 100 g rung is priced at ₹7.670 a gram while its kilo is ₹2.891, so the kilo costs less than four sample bottles. If you are going to pour 25 candles of it, buy the kilo. If you are not, the kilo is still the wrong purchase.

Four oils whose ladders tell four different stories

Each card shows every listed rung, the price per 100 g at that rung, and roughly how many candles the pack pours at 14.8 g of oil. They are picked not for how they smell but for the shape of their pricing, because that shape is what this decision turns on.

What is left over when a scent fails

Every honest comparison of these two baskets has to price the failure case, because failure is the normal case for some proportion of any first selection. Define it narrowly and conservatively: a scent passes its burn test, you pour six candles, you sell them or give them away, and then nobody asks for it again. Six candles consume 88.8 g. Everything above that is stranded.

Set the last two rows against each other, because that is the actual trade. Basket B's upside is ₹3,513.48 of cheaper oil, available only if all 201 candles get poured and sold. Basket B's downside is ₹10,735.57 of stranded oil if the three scents do not move. You are being offered roughly one unit of saving against three units of risk, on a choice you have no data to inform. Basket A offers a much smaller upside and caps the downside at ₹511.43 — about the price of one extra sample bottle.

There is a second asymmetry worth noticing. The 112 g stranded across Basket A is spread as 11.2 g in each of ten bottles, and 11.2 g is roughly one wax melt at the 10–15% melt load several of these pages state. Ten leftover melts in ten different scents is a genuinely useful thing: it is a tester set. The 911.2 g stranded in one kilo is about 7.6 kg of melt mix at a 12% load — hundreds of units of a product you have not planned. Small leftovers convert into something. Large ones become a project.

The staged route, and where the kilo belongs

The answer to the title question is not "never buy a kilo". It is "buy the kilo at stage four". Here is the full route, with the gate that opens each step and the grams it releases. Each gate is something you observe, never something you expect.

Frequently asked questions