I Made Two 100 g Reed Diffuser Batches, One with DPG and One with a Ready-Made Base — How Do I Compare Their Actual Diffusion Performance?

I Made Two 100 g Reed Diffuser Batches, One with DPG and One with a Ready-Made Base — How Do I Compare Their Actual Diffusion Performance?

 

Gold 50 ML Pack of 10 ₹826.00 Gold 120 ML Pack of 10 ₹1,062.00 Fibre reeds from ₹8.00 a reed
DPG vs ready-made base · fair comparison
Same oil, same %, same bottles and reeds; three bottles per arm, weighed and sniffed blind for 30 days.
★★★★★
"Good product👍"
Sooraj RVerified buyer · Jul 2026
Lift Base – Professional Grade Reed & Car Diffuser Base (500 ml)
★★★★★
"Nice product"
snehal ChaudharyVerified buyer · May 2026
Gold Reed Diffuser Bottle Pack of 10 (50 ML and 120 ML)
★★★★★
"Quality is good with good fragrance"
Avanthi CheeliVerified buyer · Nov 2025
Citrus Lemon Fragrance Oil
★★★★★
"Fresh and soothing"
Yashvi ShahVerified buyer · Jul 2025
Blue Ocean Fragrance Oil
★★★★☆
"Fragrances are pretty decent , quite versatile."
Tina RahaVerified buyer · Jun 2025
Lavender Fragrance Oil
★★★☆☆
"Warm comforting fragrance"
M AVerified buyer · Sep 2025
Autumn
Reviews collected and published through Judge.me on candlemakingsuppliesindia.store. They are general reviews of the products named on each card, not assessments of the advice set out below. Wording is unedited.
✓ Prices verified 7 October 2026, stock checked per variant ✓ GST invoice; MSDS and IFRA documentation for oils on request ✓ If DPG wins, keep it: CSI does not sell DPG
CSI Reed Diffusers · Fair comparison
Two batches and one bottle each is a demonstration, not a comparison. Change only the carrier, give each arm three bottles, weigh them, sniff them blind, and call a winner only when the gap beats the spread.
3 + 3 bottles
one variable, coded K and M, weighed every 3 days for 30 days · cheapest fair kit ₹1,062.00, CSI live pricing, October 2026
Quick answers — read this first
I made one 100 g batch with DPG and one with a ready-made base. How do I compare them properly? Make everything identical except the carrier, give each arm three bottles, weigh them, and sniff them blind. One bottle per batch compares two bottles, not two carriers.

I only have 100 g of each. Is that enough? For a first look, yes: split each into three 30 g fills in identical 50 ml bottles with 3 reeds each, and keep 10 g back as a stability sample. For a product decision, remake 300 g per arm and test in the 120 ml bottle you sell.

What do I measure? Weight of every bottle every 3 days (g/day), blind sniff scores on days 1, 3, 7, 14, 21 and 30 with the arms swapping rooms, clarity in a retained jar, and reed-tip condition. Decide at day 30.

What does it cost at CSI? Option 1: Gold 50 ML pack ₹826.00 + fibre reeds 25 ₹236.00 = ₹1,062.00. Option 2 with your own base: ₹1,462.00; with Pure Performance as the base arm, ₹2,437.00. CSI doesn't sell DPG.
The short answer
The trap: two batches, one bottle each, sniffed by the person who made them. That compares two bottles and one hope.
The protocol: same oil, %, mixing, rest, bottle, reeds, fill and start time; three bottles per arm; weight every 3 days; coded blind sniffs with a room swap; a retained jar for stability.
The verdict: a difference counts only if it is bigger than the spread inside each arm, and if the blind panel prefers it in at least 12 of 18 paired judgements (your rule, labelled).
The honest part: if DPG wins, keep it. We don't sell DPG, and no base always beats another.
A fair two-arm comparison, made blind Your helper codes the arms K and M and keeps the key sealed until day 30. 1 · Sniff days: the arms swap rooms Day 1 Day 3 Day 7 Day 14 Day 21 Day 30 Room 1 K M K M K M Room 2 M K M K M K Each arm: 3 sniff days per room. One bottle per arm, a different replicate each day. 30 minutes, door shut, then 3 panellists score at the doorway and at 1 m, 0–5. 2 · Between sniffs: one shelf, positions rotate every weighing window side door side Day 0 K1 M1 K2 M2 K3 M3 → shift one Day 3 M3 K1 M1 K2 M2 K3 → shift one Day 6 K3 M3 K1 M1 K2 M2 Weigh every bottle on every shift day. Sealed key opened only after day 30 scores are written.
Top: on each of six sniff days the helper puts one bottle from each arm in two similar rooms for 30 minutes, and the arms swap rooms each time. Each arm then spends three sniff days in each room, so a bigger or draughtier room can't decide the result. The arms are only ever called K and M. Bottom: between sniffs all six bottles share one shelf, and every weighing day each bottle moves one place along, so no arm lives by the window. The key is opened after day 30 scores are written.
Straight answer
I made two 100 g reed diffuser batches, one with DPG and one with a ready-made base. How do I compare their actual diffusion performance?
Treat it as a two-arm test with one variable, the carrier. First check the batches really differ only in carrier: same oil from the same bottle, same percentage, same mixing and rest. If not, remake one. Then get replicates. Split each 100 g into three 30 g fills in identical 50 ml bottles with 3 fresh reeds each, or remake 300 g per arm for three 120 ml bottles. Measure three things for 30 days: the weight of every bottle every 3 days, blind coded sniff scores on six days with the arms swapping rooms, and clarity in a retained jar at room, warm and cool. Call a winner only when the gap between arms is bigger than the spread inside each arm and your blind panel prefers it in at least two-thirds of paired judgements. If DPG wins, keep DPG.
One line: one variable (the carrier), three bottles per arm, weights every 3 days, blind sniffs with room swaps, and a verdict only when the gap beats the spread.
The cheapest fair version: split your two existing batches into six 50 ml bottles. Gold 50 ML Pack of 10 ₹826.00 + fibre reeds, pack of 25 ₹236.00 = ₹1,062.00, in stock on 7 October 2026. Your batches, your oil.
Gold bottles — from ₹826.00

Why your two batches can't be compared yet

Two bottles side by side is a demonstration, not a comparison.

Your situation, restated: two batches of 100 g each. One is fragrance oil in DPG; the other is fragrance oil in a ready-made base. You want to know which actually diffuses better. You haven't told us the oil or percentage, so the worked example uses 20 g oil + 80 g carrier in each, labelled. What matters is that the two are identical except for the carrier.

Here is what usually goes wrong. One bottle per arm. Two bottles of the same formula can differ in weight loss by a noticeable fraction because of reed fit, a warmer spot on the shelf, or a reed that wicks badly. With one bottle each, you can't tell a carrier difference from bottle-to-bottle noise. The maker sniffs. You know which bottle is which and you have a reason to prefer one. Noses are suggestible; blind coding fixes that cheaply. Room effects. The bottle in the bedroom and the bottle in the hall are in different experiments. Mismatched batches. The ready-made base page said "25-30%", so that batch got more oil. Now you're testing load and carrier together. Day-two verdicts. Reeds saturate in the first days, and early impressions are mostly about that.

"If you know which bottle is yours, your nose already knows which one should win."
— CandleMakingSuppliesIndia

None of this needs a laboratory. It needs a scale, six identical bottles, one pack of reeds, a helper with a pen and thirty days. This page is the protocol for exactly two arms. If you want to put DPG, DPM and an Augeo-type solvent side by side, that is the three-carrier comparison; a full scorecard that also weighs cost and solubility is the stop-guessing scorecard post.

What must match: the control sheet

If anything other than the carrier differs, you are no longer testing the carrier.
Control sheet · DPG batch vs ready-made base batch
Must match → how it commonly goes wrong → what to do · tick every row before day 0
Variable Must match Common mismatch What to do
Fragrance oil Same oil, same bottle of it (same lot), same grams Two different oils, or a fresh lot for one arm Check your notes. If you used different oils, remake
Load 20 g in 100 g in both (or your own %, identical) DPG at 20%, base at 25% "because the page says 25–30%" Match the % first; load is a separate test
Mixing and rest Same order, stir time, temperature, and 24–48 hour rest One mixed today, one last month Remake the older one, or rest the newer one to match
Bottle Identical glass, neck and fill weight A 120 ml jar against a 50 ml bottle Same bottle type for both arms
Reeds One pack, same count and length, fresh Five reeds against eight; used reeds in one Fresh reeds from one pack
Room and position Same shelf, rotated; same sniff rooms, swapped One by the AC vent, one by the window Rotate positions; swap rooms (diagram)
Start time Reeds into both arms within minutes Base arm started three days later Same day, same hour
Observer Coded bottles, scores written before unblinding You know which is yours and want it to win A helper codes; key sealed till day 30

The load row matters most. Ready-made base pages, ours included, give a range ("Blend with 10-30% fragrance oil") and often suggest working at 25–30%. If your DPG batch is at 20% and your base batch at 25%, the base gets 25% more fragrance to release, and any win is partly a load win. Compare at the same percentage first. Whether more oil helps is a separate question, and often a disappointing one (see the lavender load post).

What a gap between the arms can and can't tell you

A fair test isolates the carrier; it doesn't explain it. When the two arms differ, the cause still sits in one of a few places. The table separates them so you know which extra check to add if the result surprises you. Evidence is what you'd commonly see, not CSI test data.

Cause table · why one arm diffuses better
Cause → what you would see → discriminating check → fix
Cause What you would see Discriminating check Fix
Carrier volatility Base arm loses more g/day and scores higher at 1 m Carrier-only bottles (no oil) of each, weighed the same way Choose the carrier that releases inside your target rate
Carrier viscosity DPG arm's reed tips stay pale for days Time for the liquid to reach the tip in each arm Lower-viscosity carrier, or a DPG blend (the viscosity post)
Solubility / stability One arm hazes, layers or leaves film; scores drift Retained jars at room, warm and cool Reject the unstable arm, whatever it scored
Fragrance composition and load Both arms weak; or the gap shrinks with a lighter oil Repeat the two arms with a second, lighter oil The oil, not the carrier; load is a separate test
Reeds One bottle per arm far off its siblings Fresh reeds in that bottle mid-test Reed pack and fit; replace and note
Bottle and fill Rates track fill weight, not arm Weigh every fill on day 0 Identical bottles, identical fills
Room and climate Scores follow the room, not the code Room swap built in (diagram) Swap rooms; log °C and RH
Process The older batch behaves differently Remake both on one day Same mixing order, stir and rest
Measurement error Whole-gram readings; scores written after unblinding A known weight on the scale; sealed key 0.1 g or better; scores before the key

Three bottles from a 100 g batch: two options

A 100 g batch fills one 120 ml bottle. A fair test needs three.

Option 1 · split what you already made

Weigh three fills of 30 g from each batch into identical 50 ml bottles and seal the remaining 10 g in a small clear glass jar as your retained stability sample. Use 3 fresh reeds per bottle in both arms. That is 6 bottles and 18 reeds: a Gold 50 ML pack (₹826.00, 4 bottles spare) and one pack of 25 reeds (₹236.00, 7 spare), ₹1,062.00 in all. It is cheap and quick, and it is fair, because both arms get the same treatment.

Its limit is that it tells you which carrier releases faster in a small bottle with three reeds. It doesn't tell you how your 120 ml product will behave or last. The ranking usually carries over; the absolute g/day and the life don't. Use option 1 to decide whether option 2 is worth doing.

Option 2 · remake at product scale

Make a 300 g master batch per arm (60 g oil + 240 g carrier, by weight, same day, same rest) and fill three 120 ml bottles at 100 g each with 5 reeds. You need 120 g of oil in total. The CSI side: one Gold 120 ML pack (₹1,062.00, 4 spare) and one pack of 50 reeds (₹400.00). For 30 reeds, the 50 is ₹72.00 cheaper than two packs of 25. That is ₹1,462.00 if your base arm uses the base you already have. If you are choosing a CSI base for the base arm: Pure Performance needs three 100g samples (₹975.00), ₹2,437.00 in all, or Lift Base comes only in 500 ml (₹1,099.00), ₹2,561.00 in all.

Argued against our own interest: don't buy a 500 ml base just to "have enough" for a comparison you haven't run. Start with option 1 on the batches you already made. If the ready-made base doesn't clearly win there, you have saved yourself the base, the bottles and a month.

The 30-day protocol, step by step

Write the rule, code the bottles, then don't touch the key for thirty days.
1
Write the decision rule and seal itBefore day 0, write the rule from the tip box below and put it in an envelope with the date. It stops you from moving the goalposts when your favourite loses.
2
Fill, code and weigh day 0Weigh every fill (not "to the shoulder"). Your helper labels the bottles under the base, K1–K3 and M1–M3, writes which letter is DPG, seals that note, and gives you the bottles. Insert fresh reeds into all six within a few minutes of each other. Weigh each assembled bottle with reeds in.
3
One shelf, rotate on weighing daysAll six on one shelf in a normal room, away from AC vents, fans, windows and heat. Every 3 days weigh all six at the same time of day and shift each bottle one position along (diagram, bottom). That gives 11 weighings per bottle, 66 in all, to day 30.
4
Sniff blind on six days, rooms swappedOn days 1, 3, 7, 14, 21 and 30 the helper places one K and one M (a different replicate each time) in two similar closed rooms for 30 minutes, swapping rooms each day. 3 panellists, ideally people who didn't make the batches, score at the doorway and at 1 m on 0–5, then say which room smelled stronger. Fresh air between rooms. That gives 18 paired judgements.
5
Watch the retained jarsKeep the retained samples (or 20–30 g from each master in option 2) in clear closed jars at room temperature, in a warm spot such as a sunny window (labelled) and somewhere cool, for 2–4 weeks. Note haze, layering, droplets, film or colour change on each weighing day.
6
Check reeds without changing themOn weighing days, note whether reed tips look wet and dark or pale and dry. Don't flip them: flipping is its own experiment (the reed-flip post).
7
Unseal after day 30 scores are writtenWork out g/day per bottle (start minus end, divided by days), the arm means and ranges, and the paired-preference count. Then open the envelope.
Don't do these. Top up the losing arm with more oil halfway through to "give it a fair chance": you've just changed load and carrier at once. Swap in a new base, new reeds and a new room together when the first result disappoints. Judge on day 2, when the reeds are still filling. Peek at the key before the scores are written. And don't order a large drum of either carrier on the strength of a comparison that hasn't reached day 30.
Your decision rule (in-house, labelled)
(1) Rate: the gap between arm means is larger than the range inside either arm, and the faster arm is inside your own target rate (usable fill ÷ the days you want the product to last). (2) Throw: the panel prefers that arm in at least 12 of 18 paired judgements, including both day-21 and day-30 sessions. (3) Stability: its retained jars stay clear and single-phase in all three spots. (4) No surprises: no reed or bottle behaving far off its siblings without an explanation. If any part fails, the verdict is "no difference shown", not "DPG wins" or "base wins". Two-thirds is a worked suggestion; choose your own threshold before day 0.

The scoring sheet, and when a difference is real

Write everything on one sheet. You'll want it when the result is close.
Scoring sheet · one row per bottle per day
Copy into a notebook or spreadsheet · sniff columns filled only on sniff days · scores written before the key is opened
Day Bottle code Weight (g) g/day since last Doorway score (0–5) 1 m score (0–5) Clear? Layers? Film? Reed tips Room °C / RH
0 K1 ___ — — — Clear Pale ___
3 K1 ___ ___ — — ___ ___ ___
7 K1 ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___
… all six … … … … … … …

When is a difference real? Use the plain rule above: the gap between means must beat the spread inside each arm. Worked example, illustrative and not CSI data: the DPG bottles run at 1.38, 1.50 and 1.62 g/day (mean 1.50, range 0.24); the base bottles at 1.95, 2.10 and 2.31 (mean 2.12, range 0.36). The gap of 0.62 g/day is larger than both ranges, and the slowest base bottle still beats the fastest DPG bottle by 0.33 g/day. That is a real rate difference by this rule. If instead the arms overlap (one DPG bottle faster than one base bottle), you have no rate verdict, however tempting the averages look.

Faster isn't automatically better. If your target is a 60-day product with 90.00 g usable, you want about 1.50 g/day. In the worked example the DPG arm is closer to that than the base arm, which would empty sooner. If the base arm also wins the blind sniff, you may still prefer it at a lower load or with fewer reeds. That is a second test, not a conclusion from this one. Life-versus-throw is the three-month balance post.

Read the sniff scores as preferences, not measurements. A 0–5 score from three people is a structured opinion, useful because it's blind and repeated. The paired question ("which room smelled stronger?") is usually more reliable than the numbers. For a deeper treatment of the 30-day log, our live guide on testing a reed diffuser over 30 days goes further, and the evaporation method itself is the controlled evaporation-test post.

What each result means, and the purchase step

Four outcomes. Only one of them means "switch".
Outcomes · judged on the sealed rule
Rate = g/day verdict by the gap-vs-spread rule · throw = blind paired preference · stability = retained jars
Rate Throw Stability What it means Decision
Base faster Base preferred Both pass The base releases more fragrance with your oil Switch for this oil; check the life against your target; repeat with your next oil
Base faster No preference Both pass The base empties faster without smelling stronger Stay with DPG, or test the base at a lower load (oil cost falls)
No difference Either Both pass The carrier isn't what limits this diffuser Look at oil, load, reeds or room: the cluster hub lays out the order
DPG faster or equal DPG preferred Both pass Your DPG formula is the better one here Keep DPG. Spend nothing on a base
Any Any One fails The unstable arm isn't a product Reject it however it scored; check physical compatibility
Argued against our own interest, again: the bottom two rows end with you buying nothing from us but bottles and reeds, and that is the correct outcome when DPG wins. We don't sell DPG, and no base always outperforms another; that includes ours. One more caution: a win with one oil isn't a win for your range. Floral, gourmand and woody oils can rank the two carriers differently. Our live guide on testing a new base supplier before replacing the base in existing products covers rolling a change across a range.

The purchase step after a pass

Worked example, labelled: the base wins on all four rules, and you plan a first run of 40 diffusers at 100 g (20 g oil + 80 g base) with 5 reeds. You need 3,200 g of base. CSI bases are sold by volume and their pages give no density, so weigh 100 ml of the base before you order. If it comes out near 1.0 g per ml, 7 × 500 ml (₹7,693.00) covers it. Add 200 reeds as 2 × 100 (₹1,600.00) and four Gold 120 ML packs (₹4,248.00): ₹13,541.00, or ₹338.52 a bottle before oil. These are materials only, excluding labour, freight, packaging and GST. Test the first three bottles of the production lot for two weeks before you fill the rest: a new pack of base is a new lot.

Christmas is 25 December 2026; Diwali is 8 November 2026. A 30-day comparison plus a 24–48 hour rest won't hurry. If a festive run depends on the verdict, start the split test (option 1) on the batches you already have this week, and message us your counts so we can confirm stock and dispatch, with a GST invoice.
WhatsApp a stock check

What to buy for this comparison

Chosen for this comparison on page statements, price and stock on 7 October 2026. CSI publishes no performance data for its bases or reeds, which is why you are running this test. Each card says when not to buy.

1
bottle · option 1 and option 2
Gold Reed Diffuser Bottle Pack of 10 (50 ML / 120 ML)
The comparison is only fair if both arms sit in identical glass. The 50 ML pack lets you split your existing 100 g batches three ways. The 120 ML pack is what you would sell in, so it is the better test of the product. The page states no neck size and calls the range "50 and 100ml" while selling 120 ML: weigh fills, never pour to a line. Argued against our own interest: if you own six bottles of one identical type, use them and skip this.
Pack Price Per bottle For this test
50 ML Pack of 10 ₹826.00 ₹82.60 option 1: six bottles of 30 g, 4 spare
120 ML Pack of 10 ₹1,062.00 ₹106.20 option 2: six bottles of 100 g, 4 spare
Option 1 kit ₹1,062.00; option 2 bottles ₹1,062.00. Buy 120 ML 10 — ₹1,062.00
2
fibre reeds · one pack, both arms
Fiber Diffuser Reeds (Black)
Reeds from one pack, cut from nothing, never reused. Mixing reeds from two packs or two colours adds a variable you can't see. 20.3 cm long, no diameter stated, and the page's "no clogging" and "day 1 to day 30" lines are its claims, not your result. Money fact: for 30 reeds, one pack of 50 (₹400.00) is ₹72.00 cheaper than two packs of 25.
Pack Price Per reed For this test
Pack of 25 ₹236.00 ₹9.44 option 1: 18 reeds, 7 spare
Pack of 50 ₹400.00 ₹8.00 option 2: 30 reeds; cheaper than two 25s (₹472.00)
Pack of 100 ₹800.00 ₹8.00 same per reed as 50: production
Pack of 500 ₹4,000.00 ₹8.00 same per reed: no saving
From 50 up, a flat ₹8.00 a reed. Buy 50 — ₹400.00
3
ready-made base · if your base arm is a CSI base
Pure Performance Reed Base Oil (100g / 500 ML)
If you are choosing which ready-made base to put against DPG, this is the neutral one: "No added fixatives", "smooth even wicking", "Blend with 10-30% fragrance oil", rest "24-48 hours before bottling". The page publishes no composition, density, flash point or SDS. Limitation: one 100g sample is enough for one 100 g batch only (80 g of base). Option 2 needs 240 g, so three samples.
Size Price Unit price For this test
100g ₹325.00 ₹3.25 a gram three of them (₹975.00) make one 240 g base arm
500 ML ₹1,099.00 ₹2.20 a ml only after the base arm passes
One base arm for option 2: ₹975.00. Buy 100g — ₹325.00
4
ready-made base · floral, citrus, green, fruity positioning
Lift Base – Professional Grade Reed & Car Diffuser Base (500 ml)
If your oil is floral, citrus, green or fruity, the Lift page positions itself for those families ("bloom, diffuse further"). That is the page's claim, which is exactly what this comparison tests. Like every CSI base page, it states no composition, density or SDS. Limitation: sold only as 500 ml, so a test arm leaves most of the bottle unused unless the arm passes.
Size Price Per ml For this test
500 ml ₹1,099.00 ₹2.20 a ml no sample size: one bottle covers the arm and leaves about 260 ml, worth ₹571.48 at the ml price (worked at ~1 g/ml)
Option 2 kit with Lift: ₹2,561.00. Buy 500 ml — ₹1,099.00
5
fibre reeds · only if you sell white
Fiber Diffuser Reeds (White)
Test with the reed you will sell. If your product uses white reeds, use white in both arms. Same 20.3 cm length; the White page text calls them "black fiber" reeds, a copy error on the page. Limitation: about ₹1.16 a reed dearer than black in 25s; no performance difference is published either way.
Pack Price Per reed Use
Pack of 25 ₹265.00 ₹10.60 only if your product uses white reeds
Pack of 50 ₹450.00 ₹9.00 same per reed from 50 up
Pack of 100 ₹900.00 ₹9.00 —
Pack of 500 ₹4,500.00 ₹9.00 —
Black or white, never both in one test. Buy 25 — ₹265.00

Skip: a second CSI base as a third arm (that's the which-carrier decision post's territory and it costs you clarity); the CSI HyperDiffusion Base™, which is out of stock on 7 October 2026; and the Isopropyl Alcohol Spray, which is a cleaner, not an ingredient. CSI sells fibre reeds only, not rattan, so if your product uses rattan, test with your own rattan in both arms.

The CSI principle
One variable, three bottles, blind noses, sealed rules. Anything less is a preference, not a result.
For two 100 g batches, DPG against a ready-made base: split each into three, or remake at product scale; weigh every 3 days, sniff blind on six days with a room swap, and call a winner only when the gap beats the spread. The cheapest fair version costs ₹1,062.00 in bottles and reeds.
Why trust this guide

CandleMakingSuppliesIndia sells ready-made reed diffuser bases, fibre reeds and bottles, not DPG, DPM, IPM, Augeo-type solvents or perfumer's alcohol. This page still tells you to keep your DPG formula if it wins, to start with the cheapest split test, and that no base, ours included, always outperforms another. Our base pages publish no composition, density, flash point or SDS in the text we captured.

Every CSI price was checked on 7 October 2026, with stock per variant: everything priced here is in stock on that date; the CSI HyperDiffusion Base™ is out of stock and not offered. Page wording is quoted and attributed.

The worked g/day figures and the two-thirds preference threshold are illustrative or suggested, not CSI test data; the decision rule is yours. For bulk pricing, GST invoicing, and MSDS and IFRA documentation for our fragrance oils on request, message us on WhatsApp at +91 7397976926.

Frequently asked questions

How do I compare two reed diffuser bases fairly?
Change only the base: same oil and %, mixing, rest, bottle, reed pack and count, fill weight, room and start time. Use three bottles per base, weigh every 3 days, and sniff blind with coded bottles and a room swap for 30 days.
How many bottles do I need to test a reed diffuser formula?
At least three per formula. With one bottle each, normal bottle-to-bottle variation can look like a formula difference. If you have only 100 g, split it into three 30 g fills in identical small bottles.
Is DPG better than a ready-made reed diffuser base?
Neither always wins. DPG dissolves fragrance well but evaporates slowly; ready-made bases vary and rarely publish their composition. Only a fair, blind, replicated test with your oil tells you which works better for your product.
How do I do a blind sniff test for reed diffusers?
Have someone else code the bottles and keep the key sealed. Put one bottle of each formula in two similar closed rooms for 30 minutes, swap rooms on each sniff day, and have three people score and say which room smelled stronger.
How long should I compare two reed diffuser formulas?
Thirty days, with weights every 3 days and sniffs on days 1, 3, 7, 14, 21 and 30. Early days mostly show reed saturation; decide on the full run.
What does CSI recommend if my DPG formula wins?
Keep it. CSI does not sell DPG; you would buy only bottles and reeds from us. If you want to try a base later, test it at the same load with your next oil.
DPG batch vs ready-made base batch
Split each batch three ways, code the bottles, weigh every 3 days, and let a blind panel decide.
The cheapest fair version is ₹1,062.00 in Gold 50 ML bottles and fibre reeds. At product scale it is ₹1,462.00 with your own base, or ₹2,437.00 with Pure Performance as the base arm. If DPG wins, keep it.
Shop Gold Reed Diffuser Bottles Check comparison-kit stock
Editorial standards & sources
About this guide: part of CSI's cluster "DPG Reed Diffusers That Aren't Working" (8301–8320). It owns the fair two-arm comparison of a DPG batch against a ready-made base batch: the control sheet, replicates from a 100 g batch, the blind coded sniff schedule with room swaps, the scoring sheet, the gap-versus-spread rule and the outcome table. Three carriers side by side is 8328; the evaporation method is 8315.

Customer reviews: The six reviews at the top of this page are genuine, published Judge.me reviews left by CSI customers on the product pages named on each card — Autumn, Blue Ocean Fragrance Oil, Citrus Lemon Fragrance Oil, Gold Reed Diffuser Bottle Pack of 10 (50 ML and 120 ML), Lavender Fragrance Oil, Lift Base – Professional Grade Reed & Car Diffuser Base (500 ml). They are general product reviews, not assessments of the reed-diffuser formulation advice on this page. Names, star ratings, dates and products are as recorded by Judge.me and wording is unedited. "Verified buyer" appears only on reviews Judge.me recorded as verified — Sooraj R, snehal Chaudhary, Avanthi Cheeli, Yashvi Shah, Tina Raha, M A. Reviews below five stars are included as published, not filtered out.

Figures verified 7 October 2026, CSI live pricing: Gold Reed Diffuser Bottle Pack of 10, 50 ML ₹826.00 (₹82.60 each), 120 ML ₹1,062.00 (₹106.20 each); Fiber Diffuser Reeds (Black) 25 ₹236.00 (₹9.44 a reed), 50 ₹400.00, 100 ₹800.00, 500 ₹4,000.00 (₹8.00 a reed from 50 up); Fiber Diffuser Reeds (White) 25 ₹265.00 (₹10.60), 50 ₹450.00, 100 ₹900.00, 500 ₹4,500.00 (₹9.00 from 50 up); Pure Performance Reed Base Oil 100g ₹325.00, 500 ML ₹1,099.00 (₹2.20 a ml); Lift Base 500 ml ₹1,099.00; CSI HyperDiffusion Base™ ₹1,499.00 (out of stock). Every item priced is in stock on 7 October 2026 except where marked. Per unit = pack price ÷ units, two decimals. CSI does not list DPG, DPM, IPM, Augeo-type solvents or perfumer's alcohol.

Non-price figures: two 100 g batches, one DPG and one ready-made base, are the reader's (title). The 20 g oil + 80 g carrier, 30 g split fills with 3 reeds, 10 g retained sample, 300 g remake with 5 reeds, 30-day schedule, three panellists, 0–5 scale and two-thirds preference threshold are labelled worked examples or in-house suggestions. The g/day figures in the worked example and the diagram codes are illustrative, not CSI test data. The 40-bottle run assumes a density near 1.0 g/ml that you confirm by weighing. "Blend with 10-30% fragrance oil" and the 24–48 hour rest are base-page wording. Costs are materials only and exclude labour, freight, packaging and GST. Diwali 8 November 2026 and Christmas 25 December 2026 are calendar facts.
Zurück zum Blog